UPPER EAST SIDE
-
- Tal Bagels
-
333 E. 86th St.; 212-427-6811
Dense and chewy, with a strong skin for crunch and a slight sourdough tinge to the bready center. House rules: cash only, and no toasting.
UPPER WEST SIDE
-
- H&H Bagels
-
2239 Broadway; 212-595-8003
Purists insist that they’re too sweet and soft, but H&H bagels are the de facto standard, in New York and far beyond. Open 24/7 too.
MIDTOWN EAST
-
- Daniel’s Bagels
-
569 Third Ave.; 212-972-9733
None of that sweet-and-puffy nouveau thing here. Daniel’s does a New York bagel right: chewy, dense, slightly bitter.
WEST VILLAGE
-
- Murray’s Bagels
-
500 Sixth Ave.; 212-462-2830
Catching the proper balance between chewy and doughy, they’re the choice of all the area’s discerning coffee shops.
LOWER EAST SIDE
-
- Kossar’s Bialys
-
367 Grand St.; 212-473-4810
The name and the reputation lead you to its excellent bialys, but you can’t go wrong with this landmark’s satisfyingly crusty bagels either.
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
-
- Pick a Bagel
-
102 North End Ave.; 212-786-9200
Here, “a dozen” means fourteen, hand-rolled in the old style. Delivers too, for those hangover Sundays.
BOERUM HILL/COBBLE HILL/CARROLL GARDENS
-
- Court Street Bagels
-
181 Court St.; 718-624-3972
The weekend lines out the door pretty much say it all.
Best Neighborhood Bagels
From the 2007 Best of New York issue of New York Magazine
Competition breeds the best. If only one pizzeria existed in New York, of course, there’d be no real winning slice. Thankfully, we’ll never know what that sorry situation tastes like, since pizza—like dance parties, dog runs, and fried chicken—has to evolve upward here.


Email
Print



Why You Should Know Who Michael Shannon Is
Review: David Denby's Snark Misses the Point
Waltz With Bashir Makes War Feverishly Real
My Morning Jacket's Happy New Year
The Simpler Pleasures: 
Three New Men's Stores Test the Waters
Rating Ice-skating Rinks
Look Book: The Stylist
Tony Blair Settles Into His American Afterlife
Laid-Off New Yorkers Speak Out
The Young and Beautiful Arrive in The City
Bush and Barack, Not-So-Strange Bedfellows?